Is artistic talent inborn or can we cultivate it? I have always of an artist as one who
envisions what wasn’t there before and, through knowledge and experience, makes
it happen. In an article I wrote years
ago, The Poet as Patriot (Journal of Children’s Literature, v23 n2 p42-46 Fall
1997), I bemoaned the fact that the art room had been moved down the hall,
outside of our typical classroom. Since
then, the art room, along with recess, has been moved right out of the
school. Useless! Is the cry. Not rigorous. And worst of all from a
tap-every-potential-market stand point, Untestable.
envisions what wasn’t there before and, through knowledge and experience, makes
it happen. In an article I wrote years
ago, The Poet as Patriot (Journal of Children’s Literature, v23 n2 p42-46 Fall
1997), I bemoaned the fact that the art room had been moved down the hall,
outside of our typical classroom. Since
then, the art room, along with recess, has been moved right out of the
school. Useless! Is the cry. Not rigorous. And worst of all from a
tap-every-potential-market stand point, Untestable.
Our vocabulary is SO not up to date. Go to google images and type in ARTIST and up
pops a picture of a cartoon character in a beret. We are apt to define an artist as not only a
person with bad taste in hats, but also
pops a picture of a cartoon character in a beret. We are apt to define an artist as not only a
person with bad taste in hats, but also
-
Someone on the outskirts of society
-
A person who makes up stuff that may get a response out of others, but is really not productive in a societal sense and
-
Starving (see 2. re: non productive).
Why doesn’t an image search reveal a picture of
Steve Jobs or Arianna Huffington? How
about plastic surgeons who construct intact smiles out of cleft palates or
engineers who build skyscrapers out of glass and football fields out of old
tires? Are these people not
artists? What’s worse than the
perception adults hold of artists is the fact that we are teaching this same
vocabulary to our kids. I sometimes ask kids at school visits to go home and tell their parents that there was a poet and school and then suggest that now that they think about it, they would like to grow up to be a poet and watch the parental response. It’s a good laugh line. A real knee slapper. Even third graders know that their parents don’t want them to grow up to be artists.
Steve Jobs or Arianna Huffington? How
about plastic surgeons who construct intact smiles out of cleft palates or
engineers who build skyscrapers out of glass and football fields out of old
tires? Are these people not
artists? What’s worse than the
perception adults hold of artists is the fact that we are teaching this same
vocabulary to our kids. I sometimes ask kids at school visits to go home and tell their parents that there was a poet and school and then suggest that now that they think about it, they would like to grow up to be a poet and watch the parental response. It’s a good laugh line. A real knee slapper. Even third graders know that their parents don’t want them to grow up to be artists.
Michael and I
just got home from an art show at the Geauga Nature Preserve where one end of
the room was consumed by a big poster, “What if Art Ruled
the world?” My response? It does!
Look around. The people who come
up with the new technologies and problem solving fixes wind up in charge. The administrative types whose eyes are
trained to look backward at precedent, only studying what has succeeded in the past, are doomed to
fail. I don’t know if that is economics,
poetry, or basic math, but it is true.
Ask the executives at General Motors who first laughed at the
introduction of Honda cars in the U.S. and said, “let the kids buy those
toy cars, when they need a real car, they’ll come to us.” Ahem.
Any profession taken to its
highest level becomes an art form, a place where we take knowledge and
experience to create something new. The
label has become so stigmatized over the years that we keep coming up with new
names for artists. We call them entrepreneurs,
inventors, creative problem solvers.
Maybe if we started calling the artists in our midst by their true
names, we wouldn’t be so hesitant to spend some time nurturing artistry in our
schools. Seth Godin in his article, 3 Essential Skills Every Entrepreneur Should Cultivate, cites three qualities to nurture: 1. Quiet the Lizard
Brain, which means silence the resistant part of your brain that is responsible
for fear and rage. 2. Think like an artist, where he notes that, “Art requires
the artist to care, and to care enough to do something when he knows it might
not work,” and 3. Connect the disconnected, this he recommends as a route
to problem solving. I haven’t read this
guy’s book, but I like his line of thinking in this article. It
gives credit where credit is due — to the artists and the risk takers.
highest level becomes an art form, a place where we take knowledge and
experience to create something new. The
label has become so stigmatized over the years that we keep coming up with new
names for artists. We call them entrepreneurs,
inventors, creative problem solvers.
Maybe if we started calling the artists in our midst by their true
names, we wouldn’t be so hesitant to spend some time nurturing artistry in our
schools. Seth Godin in his article, 3 Essential Skills Every Entrepreneur Should Cultivate, cites three qualities to nurture: 1. Quiet the Lizard
Brain, which means silence the resistant part of your brain that is responsible
for fear and rage. 2. Think like an artist, where he notes that, “Art requires
the artist to care, and to care enough to do something when he knows it might
not work,” and 3. Connect the disconnected, this he recommends as a route
to problem solving. I haven’t read this
guy’s book, but I like his line of thinking in this article. It
gives credit where credit is due — to the artists and the risk takers.
I hate when a well-meaning
educator introduces me to a kid at a school as: This is our poet. It discounts the other kids in the room or
school who are also nurturing poetical observations and metaphorical connections they just haven’t found the
words for yet. Or maybe they will never
express themselves in words, maybe they will use mathematical equations,
chemical formulas or organizational genius. It implies that as
long as we have one kid with a poetic eye in our midst, the rest of the kids can (should?)
stand down, not risk their own self expression. The fact is, every one of
them will need the careful, observational skills of a poet at some point. They will need to be artists, to draw on their creative abilities to problem solve.
educator introduces me to a kid at a school as: This is our poet. It discounts the other kids in the room or
school who are also nurturing poetical observations and metaphorical connections they just haven’t found the
words for yet. Or maybe they will never
express themselves in words, maybe they will use mathematical equations,
chemical formulas or organizational genius. It implies that as
long as we have one kid with a poetic eye in our midst, the rest of the kids can (should?)
stand down, not risk their own self expression. The fact is, every one of
them will need the careful, observational skills of a poet at some point. They will need to be artists, to draw on their creative abilities to problem solve.
As Susan Ohanian points out so eloquently in her article: Against Obedience Critical Education, 3(9)., “We need artists, bakers, lumberjacks, manicurists, welders, and yurt builders,
as well as people who study math and science in college. Let’s respect the
variety of skills needed in our communities–and make sure everyone receives
a decent wage.” Of the wild flower bouquet of skills needed to make society function, we need an artist at the velvet heart of every blossom.
as well as people who study math and science in college. Let’s respect the
variety of skills needed in our communities–and make sure everyone receives
a decent wage.” Of the wild flower bouquet of skills needed to make society function, we need an artist at the velvet heart of every blossom.
Enter uniform proficiency tests
and standards that reward conformity and compliance and it becomes evident that our schools may not be preparing kids for all of their tomorrows. Being able to black out little boxes with a
number 2 pencil is not going to help students care for future families in a
precarious world. We are feeding these students
a false narrative: If you fall in line and memorize what we ask you to, you
will reap rewards. Not true. If you are creative and an evaluative risk taker who uses
knowledge and experience to make stuff up, that’s what is going to put food on
your table and advance your pursuit of happiness. In order to respond when the future asks, how do we position this product? How can we cure this malady or design this
to be more efficient in terms of cost and resources. How can we expedite this
procedure? The adult, 2.0 versions of
the kids sitting in classrooms today will most likely be collaborating and
making up stuff like crazy, connecting all kinds of disconnected dots and
inserting a few that weren’t there before trying to service the needs of future
generations and clean up the messes previous generations have created. Successful adults are their own bosses,
whether working inside of some institution or self-employed. Kids will need to be so much more than compliant.
and standards that reward conformity and compliance and it becomes evident that our schools may not be preparing kids for all of their tomorrows. Being able to black out little boxes with a
number 2 pencil is not going to help students care for future families in a
precarious world. We are feeding these students
a false narrative: If you fall in line and memorize what we ask you to, you
will reap rewards. Not true. If you are creative and an evaluative risk taker who uses
knowledge and experience to make stuff up, that’s what is going to put food on
your table and advance your pursuit of happiness. In order to respond when the future asks, how do we position this product? How can we cure this malady or design this
to be more efficient in terms of cost and resources. How can we expedite this
procedure? The adult, 2.0 versions of
the kids sitting in classrooms today will most likely be collaborating and
making up stuff like crazy, connecting all kinds of disconnected dots and
inserting a few that weren’t there before trying to service the needs of future
generations and clean up the messes previous generations have created. Successful adults are their own bosses,
whether working inside of some institution or self-employed. Kids will need to be so much more than compliant.
We need to find a way to reward
thoughtful risk taking in school. Eleanor Roosevelt advised, “do one thing
every day that scares you.” We need
an assessment rubric for that one, accomplished, showing signs of progress, or
needs improvement. Or make this a criteria for assessment: Student applies logic in assessing risks. How about: Student demonstrates an ability to
discover and achieve as part of a team (not involving a ball)? Or:
Shows unlikely but valid connections across content areas and is able to
communicate ideas in a convincing manner using words, images, coding, mechanical
devices or movement. Where is the
assessment rubric for curiosity or tenacity? Most of all, schools need to stop buying programs that promise to help kids on tests and start looking for ways to foster creativity. Toss the fill in the blanks worksheets and bring back the crayons and blocks.
thoughtful risk taking in school. Eleanor Roosevelt advised, “do one thing
every day that scares you.” We need
an assessment rubric for that one, accomplished, showing signs of progress, or
needs improvement. Or make this a criteria for assessment: Student applies logic in assessing risks. How about: Student demonstrates an ability to
discover and achieve as part of a team (not involving a ball)? Or:
Shows unlikely but valid connections across content areas and is able to
communicate ideas in a convincing manner using words, images, coding, mechanical
devices or movement. Where is the
assessment rubric for curiosity or tenacity? Most of all, schools need to stop buying programs that promise to help kids on tests and start looking for ways to foster creativity. Toss the fill in the blanks worksheets and bring back the crayons and blocks.
We need to bury the berets and
bring out the true artist in every child, every day, in every academic discipline.
bring out the true artist in every child, every day, in every academic discipline.
Well written as always Sara. I agree with everything you wrote. If kids are willing to put in the time and effort art is something that they can make AND make a living at it. To paraphrase Allan Wolf they can as internally rich "as kings and queens."
Amen, sister!